REFERENCE TITLE: victims' rights; requirements; monetary judgments

 

 

 

State of Arizona

House of Representatives

Fifty-third Legislature

First Regular Session

2017

 

 

HB 2269

 

Introduced by

Representatives Syms: Barton, Bowers, Cook, John, Kern, Leach, Mitchell, Nutt, Payne, Rubalcava, Senator Fann

 

 

AN ACT

 

amending sections 8‑386, 8‑386.01, 8‑387, 8‑396, 8‑407, 8‑413 and 8‑415, Arizona Revised Statutes; amending title 12, chapter 9, Arizona Revised Statutes, by adding article 12; amending sections 13‑4405, 13‑4407, 13‑4415 and 13‑4428, Arizona Revised Statutes; relating to victims' rights.

 

 

(TEXT OF BILL BEGINS ON NEXT PAGE)

 


Be it enacted by the Legislature of the State of Arizona:

Section 1.  Section 8-386, Arizona Revised Statutes, is amended to read:

START_STATUTE8-386.  Information provided to victim by law enforcement agencies

A.  As soon after the detection of an offense as the victim may be contacted without interfering with an investigation or arrest, the law enforcement agency responsible for investigating the offense shall provide electronic forms, pamphlets, information cards or other materials to the victim with a multicopy form:

1.  That allows the victim to request or waive applicable rights to which the victim is entitled, on request, under this article.

2.  That provides the victim a method to designate a lawful representative if the victim so chooses pursuant to section 8‑384, subsection A or section 8‑385.

3.  That provides notice to the victim of all of the following information:

(a)  The victim's right under the victims' bill of rights, article II, section 2.1, Constitution of Arizona, to be treated with fairness, respect and dignity and to be free of intimidation, harassment or abuse throughout the criminal or juvenile justice process.

(b)  The availability, if any, of crisis intervention services and emergency and medical services and, if applicable, that medical expenses arising out of the need to secure evidence may be reimbursed pursuant to section 13‑1414.

(c)  In cases involving domestic violence, the procedures and resources available for the protection of the victim pursuant to section 13‑3601.

(d)  The names and telephone numbers of public and private victim assistance programs, including the county victim compensation program and programs that provide counseling, treatment and other support services.

(e)  The police report number, if available, other identifying case information and the following statement:

If within thirty days you are not notified of an arrest in your case, you may call (the law enforcement agency's telephone number) for the status of the case.

(f)  Whether the suspect is an adult or juvenile, the victim will be notified by the law enforcement agency at the earliest opportunity after the arrest of a suspect.

(g)  If the suspect is a juvenile and the officer requests that the accused be detained, a statement of the victim's right, on request, to be informed if the juvenile will be released or will be detained pending the detention hearing and of the victim's right to be present and heard at the detention hearing and that, to exercise these rights, the victim must contact the detention screening section of the juvenile probation department immediately to request notice of all of the following:

(i)  The juvenile's release.

(ii)  The date, time and place of the detention hearing and any changes to that schedule.

(iii)  If the victim chooses to exercise the right to be heard through a written statement, how that statement may be submitted to the court.

(h)  That the victim or the immediate family member of the victim, if the victim is killed or incapacitated, has the right to receive one copy of the police report, including any supplements to the report, from the investigating law enforcement agency at no charge pursuant to section 39-127.

B.  If at the time of contact with a law enforcement agency the victim is physically or emotionally unable to request or waive applicable rights, the law enforcement agency shall designate this on the multicopy form in a format that is authorized by subsection A of this section and the entities that may be subsequently affected shall presume that the victim invoked the victim's right to request applicable rights to which the victim is entitled, on request, unless the victim later waives those rights.

C.  The law enforcement agency shall submit one copy of the victim's request or waiver of predisposition rights form to the detention center, if the arresting officer is requesting that the accused be detained, at the time the juvenile is taken to detention.  If detention is not requested, the form copies shall be submitted to the juvenile probation intake section at the time the case is otherwise referred to court.  The probation intake section shall submit a copy of the victim's request or waiver of predisposition rights form to the prosecutor and the departments or governmental agencies, as applicable, that are mandated by this article to provide victims' rights services on request.

D.  If the accused juvenile is cited and released by an Arizona traffic ticket and complaint form pursuant to section 8‑323, the law enforcement agency shall inform the victim how to obtain additional information about subsequent proceedings.

E.  Law enforcement agencies within a county may establish different procedures designed to efficiently and effectively provide notice of the victim's rights pursuant to this article and notice to affected entities of victim request or waiver information.  If different procedures are established, the procedures shall:

1.  Be reported to the entities within a county affected by the procedures and reported to the attorney general.

2.  Be designed so that detention centers within a county receive notice of the victim's request or waiver of the victim's predisposition rights at the same time that an accused juvenile is detained.

3.  Be designed so that the juvenile probation intake section of the county receives notice of the victim's request or waiver of the victim's predisposition rights at the same time that the case is referred to court.

4.  Provide that the notice to affected entities of a victim's request or waiver of the victim's predisposition rights includes information that allows the affected entity to contact the victim.

5.  Be supported by the use of electronic forms, brochures, forms or other written materials developed by the law enforcement agencies within a county and reviewed by the attorney general pursuant to section 8‑398, subsection B. END_STATUTE

Sec. 2.  Section 8-386.01, Arizona Revised Statutes, is amended to read:

START_STATUTE8-386.01.  Issuance and execution of arrest warrants

A.  Beginning on the effective date of this section, On the issuance of an arrest warrant, the court issuing the warrant shall state in the warrant whether the person named in the warrant is to be arrested for or is to be charged with committing an offense to which this article applies or that is materially related to an offense to which this article applies.

B.  On receipt of notice of an arrest or an impending arrest of a juvenile and if applicable pursuant to subsection A of this section, the agency that is responsible for holding the original warrant shall notify the law enforcement agency that was responsible for the original investigation of the offense of the impending detainment of the juvenile who is arrested on the law enforcement agency's warrant.

C.  On receiving notice that the warrant was executed pursuant to subsection B of this section, the law enforcement agency that was responsible for the original investigation of the offense shall do all of the following if the victim has requested notice pursuant to section 8‑286 8‑386:

1.  Notify the victim of the arrest and advise the victim that to exercise the right to be informed if the juvenile is released the victim must contact the detention center of the juvenile probation department immediately.

2.  Inform the victim of the telephone number of the detention center in which the juvenile is detained.

3.  Provide the detention center with the victim information pursuant to section 8‑286 8‑386 so that the detention center may notify the victim of the release or escape of the juvenile pursuant to section 8‑290.03 8‑393, if applicable.

D.  A law enforcement agency is not required to provide victim information pursuant to section 8‑286 8‑386, subsections C and E to the custodial agency at the time a juvenile is detained unless the law enforcement agency that performs the warrant arrest is also the law enforcement agency that was responsible for the original investigation of the offense.

E.  The victim's right to be informed of an arrest or a release pursuant to an executed warrant applies to warrants that are issued on or after September 1, 1996.

F.  Law enforcement, courts and juvenile custodial agencies are not liable pursuant to section 8‑290.26 8‑393 for the failure to inform a victim of the arrest or release of a juvenile on warrants that were issued before September 1, 1996. END_STATUTE

Sec. 3.  Section 8-387, Arizona Revised Statutes, is amended to read:

START_STATUTE8-387.  Notice of terms and conditions of release

On the request of the victim, the juvenile court or the department of juvenile corrections shall provide a copy of the terms and conditions of release. The copy of the terms and conditions of release may be provided to the victim in an electronic form, pamphlet, information card or other material. END_STATUTE

Sec. 4.  Section 8-396, Arizona Revised Statutes, is amended to read:

START_STATUTE8-396.  Notice of probation modification, termination or revocation disposition matters; notice of arrest

A.  On request of a victim who has provided an address or other contact information, the court shall notify the victim of any of the following:

1.  A probation revocation disposition proceeding or any proceeding in which the court is asked to terminate the probation or intensive probation of the delinquent who committed the delinquent act against the victim.

2.  Any hearing on a proposed modification of the terms of probation or intensive probation.

3.  The arrest of a delinquent pursuant to a warrant issued for a probation violation.

B.  On request of a victim who has provided a current address or other current contact information, the probation department shall notify the victim of the following:

1.  Any proposed modification to any term of probation if the modification affects restitution or incarceration status or the delinquent's contact with or the safety of the victim.

2.  The victim's right to be heard at a hearing that is set to consider any modification to be made to any term of probation.

3.  Any violation of any term of probation that results in the filing with the court of a petition to revoke probation.

4.  That a petition to revoke probation alleging that the juvenile absconded from probation has been filed with the court.

5.  Any conduct by the juvenile that raises a substantial concern for the victim's safety.

C.  If a victim has requested postadjudication notice and probation is revoked and the juvenile is committed to the department of juvenile corrections, the court probation department shall notify the department of juvenile corrections of the victim's request.

D.  On request of the victim, the department of juvenile corrections shall notify the victim of any of the following:

1.  Any proceeding in which the department may revoke the conditional liberty of the delinquent who committed the delinquent act against the victim.

2.  A modification of the terms of conditional liberty only if the modification will substantially affect the delinquent's contact with the victim or the safety of the victim or if the modification affects restitution or secure care status.

3.  The arrest of a delinquent pursuant to a warrant issued for a conditional liberty violation.END_STATUTE

Sec. 5.  Section 8-407, Arizona Revised Statutes, is amended to read:

START_STATUTE8-407.  Victim's discretion; form of statement

A.  The victim has discretion to exercise the victim's rights under this article to be present and be heard at a court proceeding, and the absence of the victim at the court proceeding does not preclude the court from continuing the proceeding.

B.  Except as provided in subsection C of this section, a victim's right to be heard may be exercised through an oral statement, submission of a written statement or submission of a statement through audiotape or videotape or any other video or digital media.

C.  If a person against whom a delinquent act has been committed is in custody for an offense, the person may be heard by submitting a written statement to the court. END_STATUTE

Sec. 6.  Section 8-413, Arizona Revised Statutes, is amended to read:

START_STATUTE8-413.  Victim's right to privacy; exception; definitions

A.  The victim has the right at any court proceeding not to testify regarding any identifying or locating information unless the victim consents or the court orders disclosure on finding that a compelling need for the information exists.  A court proceeding on the motion shall be in camera.

B.  A victim's identifying and locating information that is obtained, compiled or reported by a law enforcement agency or prosecution agency shall be redacted by the originating agency and prosecution agencies from records pertaining to the criminal case involving the victim, including discovery disclosed to the defendant.

C.  Subsection B of this section does not apply to:

1.  The victim's name except, if the victim is a minor, the victim's name may be redacted from public records pertaining to the crime if the countervailing interests of confidentiality, privacy, the rights of the minor or the best interests of this state outweigh the public interest in disclosure.

2.  Any records that are transmitted between law enforcement and prosecution agencies or a court.

3.  Any records if the victim or, if the victim is a minor, the victim's representative as designated under section 8‑384 or 13‑4403 has consented to the release of the information.

4.  The general location at which the reported crime occurred.

D.  For the purposes of this section:

1.  "Identifying information" includes a victim's date of birth, social security number and official state or government issued driver license or identification number.

2.  "Locating information" includes the victim's address, telephone number, e‑mail address and place of employment. END_STATUTE

Sec. 7.  Section 8-415, Arizona Revised Statutes, is amended to read:

START_STATUTE8-415.  Effect of failure to comply

A.  The failure to comply with a victim's constitutional or statutory right is a ground for the victim to request a reexamination proceeding within ten days after the proceeding at which the victim's right was denied or with leave of the court for good cause shown.  After the victim requests a reexamination proceeding and after the court gives reasonable notice, the court shall afford the victim a reexamination proceeding to consider the issues raised by the denial of the victim's right.  Except as provided in subsection B of this section, the court shall reconsider any decision that arises from a proceeding in which the victim's right was not protected and shall ensure that the victim's rights are thereafter protected.

B.  The failure to use reasonable efforts to perform a duty or provide a right is not cause to seek to set aside an adjudication or disposition after trial.  Failure to afford a right under this chapter shall not provide grounds for a new trial.  A victim who was given notice of a plea or sentencing proceeding may make a motion to reopen a plea or sentence only if the victim was not voluntarily absent from the proceeding and has asserted the right to be heard before or during the proceeding at issue and the right to be heard was denied and, in the case of a plea, the accused has not pled to the highest offense charged.  This subsection does not affect the victim's right to restitution, which the victim may seek to enforce at any time.

C.  Unless the juvenile is discharged from the juvenile's sentence, the failure to use reasonable efforts to provide notice and a right to be present or be heard pursuant to this chapter at a proceeding that involves a postconviction postadjudication release is a ground for the victim to seek to set aside the postconviction postadjudication release until the victim is afforded the opportunity to be present or be heard.

D.  If the victim seeks to have a postconviction postadjudication release set aside pursuant to subsection C of this section, the court or department of juvenile corrections shall afford the victim a reexamination proceeding after the parties are given notice.

E.  A reexamination proceeding conducted pursuant to this section or any other proceeding that is based on the failure to perform a duty or provide a right shall commence not more than thirty days after the appropriate parties have been given notice that the victim is exercising the right to a reexamination proceeding pursuant to this section or to another proceeding based on the failure to perform a duty or provide a right.  END_STATUTE

Sec. 8.  Title 12, chapter 9, Arizona Revised Statutes, is amended by adding article 12, to read:

ARTICLE 12.  MONETARY JUDGMENT AWARDS TO PRISONERS

START_STATUTE12-1721.  Monetary judgment awarded to prisoners; outstanding restitution and incarceration costs

A.  In any civil action, a monetary judgment may not be paid to a person who is or was previously incarcerated in the state department of corrections before all restitution and incarceration costs owed by the person are paid if the monetary judgment is against this state, a political subdivision of this state, any prison, jail or correctional facility or any officer or agent of a prison, jail or correctional facility.  If the monetary judgment is not sufficient to pay both restitution and incarceration costs that are owed, the monetary judgment must first be used to pay any outstanding restitution and any remaining balance may be used to pay outstanding incarceration costs.

B.  If the victim was ordered by the court to receive restitution through the clerk of the superior court, this state, the political subdivision of this state or the prison, jail or correctional facility that was ordered to provide the monetary judgment may transfer the money to the clerk of the superior court for distribution to the victim.  END_STATUTE

Sec. 9.  Section 13-4405, Arizona Revised Statutes, is amended to read:

START_STATUTE13-4405.  Information provided to victim by law enforcement agencies

A.  As soon after the detection of a criminal offense as the victim may be contacted without interfering with an investigation or arrest, the law enforcement agency that has responsibility for investigating the criminal offense shall provide electronic forms, pamphlets, information cards or other materials to the victim with a multicopy form:

1.  That allows the victim to request or waive applicable rights to which the victim is entitled, on request, under this article.

2.  That provides the victim a method to designate a lawful representative if the victim chooses pursuant to section 13‑4403, subsection A or section 13‑4404.

3.  That provides notice to the victim of all of the following information:

(a)  The victim's right under the victims' bill of rights, article II, section 2.1, Constitution of Arizona, to be treated with fairness, respect and dignity and to be free of intimidation, harassment or abuse throughout the criminal or juvenile justice process.

(b)  The availability, if any, of crisis intervention services and emergency and medical services and, where applicable, that medical expenses arising out of the need to secure evidence may be reimbursed pursuant to section 13‑1414.

(c)  In cases of domestic violence, the procedures and resources available for the protection of the victim pursuant to section 13‑3601.

(d)  The names and telephone numbers of public and private victim assistance programs, including the county victim compensation program and programs that provide counseling, treatment and other support services.

(e)  The police report number, if available, other identifying case information and the following statement:

If within thirty days you are not notified of an arrest in your case, you may call (the law enforcement agency's telephone number) for the status of the case.

(f)  Whether the suspect is an adult or juvenile, a statement that the victim will be notified by the law enforcement agency at the earliest opportunity after the arrest of a suspect.

(g)  If the suspect is an adult and has been arrested, the victim's right, on request, to be informed of the suspect's release, of the next regularly scheduled time, place and date for initial appearances in the jurisdiction and of the victim's right to be heard at the initial appearance and that, to exercise these rights, the victim is advised to contact the custodial agency regarding the suspect's release and to contact the court regarding any changes to the initial appearance schedule.

(h)  If the victim chooses to exercise the right to be heard through a written statement, how that statement may be submitted to the court.

(i)  That the victim or the immediate family member of the victim, if the victim is killed or incapacitated, has the right to receive one copy of the police report, including any supplements to the report, from the investigating law enforcement agency at no charge pursuant to section 39‑127.

B.  If at the time of contact with a law enforcement agency the victim is physically or emotionally unable to request or waive applicable rights, the law enforcement agency shall designate this on the multicopy form in the format that is authorized by subsection A of this section and the entities that may be subsequently affected shall presume that the victim invoked the victim's right to request applicable rights to which the victim is entitled, on request, unless the victim later waives those rights.

C.  The law enforcement agency shall submit a copy of the victim's request or waiver of preconviction rights form to the custodial agency and a copy to the prosecutor if a suspect is arrested, at the time the suspect is taken into custody.  If there is no arrest, the form copies shall be submitted to the prosecutor at the time the case is otherwise presented to the prosecutor for review.  The prosecutor shall submit a copy of the victim's request or waiver of preconviction rights form to the departments or sections of the prosecutor's office, if applicable, that are mandated by this article to provide victims' rights services on request.

D.  If the suspected offender is cited and released, the law enforcement agency responsible for investigating the offense shall inform the victim of the court date and how to obtain additional information about the subsequent criminal proceedings.

E.  Law enforcement agencies within a county may establish different procedures designed to efficiently and effectively provide notice of the victim's rights pursuant to this section and notice to affected entities of the victim request or waiver information.  If different procedures are established, the procedures shall:

1.  Be reported to the entities within a county affected by the procedures and reported to the attorney general.

2.  Be designed so that custodial agencies and prosecutors within a county receive notice of the victim's request or waiver of the victim's preconviction rights at the same time that an adult suspect is arrested.

3.  Be designed so that prosecutors within a county receive notice of the victim's request or waiver of the victim's preconviction rights, if there is no arrest, at the same time that the case is otherwise presented to the prosecutor for review.

4.  Provide that the notice to affected entities of a victim's request or waiver of the victim's preconviction rights includes information that affords the affected entity the ability to contact the victim.

5.  Be supported by use of electronic forms, brochures, forms or other written materials that are developed by the law enforcement agencies within a county and reviewed by the attorney general pursuant to section 13‑4417, subsection B.

F.  If a suspect has not been arrested at the time of contact with the victim pursuant to subsection A of this section, the law enforcement agency that is responsible for investigating the offense shall notify the victim of the arrest of a suspect at the earliest opportunity after the arrest and of the time, place and date for the initial appearance.END_STATUTE

Sec. 10.  Section 13-4407, Arizona Revised Statutes, is amended to read:

START_STATUTE13-4407.  Notice of terms and conditions of release

Upon On the request of the victim, the custodial agency shall provide a copy of the terms and conditions of release to the victim unless the accused appeared in response to a summons.  In that case, upon on request of the victim, the prosecutor's office shall, on receiving such information, shall provide a copy of the terms and conditions of release to the victim.  The copy of the terms and conditions of release may be provided to the victim in an electronic form, pamphlet, information card or other material. END_STATUTE

Sec. 11.  Section 13-4415, Arizona Revised Statutes, is amended to read:

START_STATUTE13-4415.  Notice of probation modification, termination or revocation disposition matters; notice of arrest

A.  On request of a victim who has provided an address or other contact information, the court shall notify the victim of any of the following:

1.  A probation revocation disposition proceeding or any proceeding in which the court is asked to terminate the probation or intensive probation of a person who is convicted of committing a criminal offense against the victim.

2.  Any hearing on a proposed modification of the terms of probation or intensive probation.

3.  The arrest of a person who is on supervised probation and who is arrested pursuant to a warrant issued for a probation violation.

B.  On request of a victim who has provided a current address or other current contact information, the probation department shall notify the victim of the following:

1.  Any proposed modification to any term of probation if the modification affects restitution or incarceration status or the defendant's contact with or the safety of the victim.

2.  The victim's right to be heard at a hearing that is set to consider any modification to be made to any term of probation.

3.  Any violation of any term of probation that results in the filing with the court of a petition to revoke probation.

4.  That a petition to revoke probation alleging that the defendant absconded from probation has been filed with the court.

5.  Any conduct by the defendant that raises a substantial concern for the victim's safety.

C.  If a victim has requested postconviction notice, the court shall provide notice of that request to the state department of corrections and the board of executive clemency if a defendant's probation is revoked and the defendant is committed to the custody of the state department of corrections.

D.  On the request of a victim, the state department of corrections shall provide the victim with the notices that are required by sections 13‑4412 and 13‑4413.

E.  On the request of the victim, the board of executive clemency shall provide the victim with the notice that is required by section 13‑4414.END_STATUTE

Sec. 12.  Section 13-4428, Arizona Revised Statutes, is amended to read:

START_STATUTE13-4428.  Victim's discretion; form of statement

A.  It is at the victim's discretion to exercise his the victim's rights under this chapter to be present and heard at a court proceeding, and the absence of the victim at the court proceeding does not preclude the court from going forth with the proceeding.

B.  Except as provided in subsection C of this section, a victim's right to be heard may be exercised, at the victim's discretion, through an oral statement, submission of a written statement or submission of a statement through audiotape or videotape or any other video or digital media.

C.  If a person against whom a criminal offense has been committed is in custody for an offense, the person may be heard by submitting a written statement to the court. END_STATUTE